Opencaching.com – Garmin’s new cache listing site!


Just when OpenCaching was starting to accumulate a good number of caches along came another Geocaching site, OpenCaching! Er, wait… Didn’t I just say that??? Yes I did. In case you weren’t aware, Geocaching.com is not the only cache listing site out there. There is also navicache, Terracaching, and quite recently a trend of ‘OpenCaching’ with sites for each country (opencaching.org.uk, opencaching.eu, opencaching.us, etc.) These opencaching sites are focused on being completely free, so there is no members fee. Also you have more choices on what types of cache you can submit. E.g. Webcam and virtuals are allowed.

This new opencaching site that has caused quite a stir is opencaching.com and despite having the same name is not under the same umbrella as all of the other opencaching sites, instead it is associated with our good friends GARMIN!!! Hmmm…

At least the graphics are cute!

The site is still in early beta stages and behaves very buggy to say the least, however the overall site layout looks neat. One would hope that a new listing site would mean new unique caches, however it actively encourages you to upload your cache hides that are already on Geocaching.com via an import tool. Having the same cache listed in many places may seem like a good way to get more finders, however sounds like a real pain to maintain. How can you ensure that the cache owner hasn’t forgotten to update their opencaching.com listing if coords change or if it gets disabled on geocaching.com? And what if you go for an FTF to submit to Geocaching.com when someone who only uses Opencaching.com has already been there and signed the logbook? In my opinion any type of redundant data is something that should really be avoided!

Import your hides and finds

There are so far a few caches here and there over the UK. The map search is however quite nice, as are the little circles that show cache ratings.

Opencaches in the UK (so far)

As well as size, difficulty, and terrain there is Awesomeness!

Awesomeness ratings for caches

I’m concerned at the review process in that there isn’t one. On the listing submission page there is a tickbox that says “I have permission from the landowner or manager to hide my geocache.” Some may moan about reviewers taking time to publish, or being very picky with listings, etc. But at the end of the day they are there to help us, for free! The last thing I want is to trespass onto land that I shouldn’t be on. I know that by finding caches from geocaching.com they will have been checked by a reviewer and although they can’t check absolutely everything they can catch most dodgy locations and I rarely feel like I shouldn’t be somewhere when searching for a cache. However, I can’t say the same about this new site. Another thing that interests me in the site is its set of guidelines. They are quite brief, however one thing in particular did catch my eye: “Don’t hide your caches on cliffs, down abandoned mines, in trenches or anywhere that might put the safety of geocachers in peril” I have found a 5/5 down an abandoned mine (And it was amazing fun) and I know of many up in the Peak District that are up on cliffs. There are also quite a lot of extreme Geocaches out and about that would probably go against this guideline.

To find the location of caches on opencaching.com you don’t need to have an account. Any old muggle can just go to the website and search. On the geocaching site you can indeed do the same, however the actual coordinates are hidden until you login. This is indeed the same on the other opencaching sites. I’ve read on the forums about a group called GROEP (this is old news and has been happening for years so is just one example) whose main goal is to sabotage caches. They however have to sign up and as soon as they are found to be abusing the system have their accounts banned. You can still check ip addresses through a lot of ISP’s so these users are trackable. I do worry about a site where geocache hides can be anonymously browsed and found, especially when it’s endorsed by Garmin.

Viewing Geocaching.com without being a member

An example of a listing

I signed up and attempted to create a cache on Opencaching just as a test to look at the submission process. I got through step 1 where I gave the cache name and the coordinates, however step 2 was just a blank page and some exception was raised that stopped me continuing. I would have thought really important bugs like these would have been ironed out in the Alpha stage rather than let it get to beta as it is slightly important that you can actually add caches to a cache listing site!!! However, I guess it was working at some point or another as there are a few caches on there already.

At the moment I’m about as excited about this as I was the chirp (not very!) and feel that Garmin are trying to fill a hole that doesn’t exist. Perhaps it did a few years ago, but I fail to see a reason behind it now. Oh, apart from to sell more Garmin units! πŸ˜‰ Garmin certainly seem to be taking an interest in caching recently. First there was the chirp that Groundspeak knew nothing about until a few days before its release, and now this brand new listing site. I cant help thinking that perhaps everyone would benefit more if Garmin worked *with* Groundspeak rather than against them! The site is still in its early stages so we shall wait and see how it unfolds…

Does anyone else have any opinions on this new listing site?

Advertisements

6 Responses to “Opencaching.com – Garmin’s new cache listing site!”

  1. Cache Mania Says:

    As I wrote on my blog this new site isn’t about competing with geocaching it is about selling more GPSr units. That’s not necessarily a bad thing. Groundspeak has a 10 year head start. Garmin is going to make a lot of mistakes. Only time will tell if this site will flourish.

  2. geocass Says:

    Thanks for your comment. Im just not keen on all of these “Garmin launch a free geocaching site” surely that is implying that Geocaching.com isn’t free at all, which is not true. There are loads of things you can do ok geocaching.com which are free. I’m very pleased that I have the option to make my caches premium only in case we ever have a wave of mad cache thieves that I can at least try something to make my cache less of a target. I do like their little character though, ‘Opie’ he’s very cute πŸ™‚ I also like the fact that they talked with GAGB and have links to their guidelines on their pages. I will wait to see if this takes off. If it’s to sell more Garmin units then i don’t think it’s going to benefit them all that much over here in the UK as we have very few other handheld GPS retailers over here. I’ve never bumped into a Geocacher that wasn’t using a Garmin GPS. Fair enough some were using smartphones, but I don’t see how the site is going to switch smartphone users to Garmin GPSr’s especially when there’s an open API so anyone can program a smartphone app to communicate with the site…

    But yes, we will wait and see πŸ™‚

  3. DudleyGrunt Says:

    Correction – The true OpenCaching community has been around since 2005, but has had recent growth, including OpenCaching US (www.opencaching.us). Garmin is using the name, but has no conneciton to and has no communication with the powers that be in the original OpenCaching community.

    I hope folks will come check out the REAL OpenCaching. See http://www.opencaching.eu for OC sites in other countries.

    Happy Trails,
    Dave

    • geocass Says:

      Thanks for your comments. 2005, wow! I believe our UK one is more recent though, isn’t it? It’s interesting to see that Garmin have chosen the same name especially for a site that has been around for that long…

  4. Explore the outdoors: Part 3 – Geocaching.com alternatives « GeoCass UK GeoCaching Says:

    […] NaviCache, Opencaching, TerraCaching and also just recently OpenCaching.com. I thought as I’d already blogged about the new OpenCaching.com site that it’d only be fair to give the other sites a bit of the […]


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s